Vibrant Nation

Suzanne Braun Levine: Learning to say no and how it changed my life

Suzanne Braun Levine is a writer, editor and nationally recognized authority on women, parenting and family issues, and media. She has defined a new stage of life - Women in Second Adulthood - and continues to report on the changes in women’s lives in her books and on her website www.suzannebraunlevine.com. Her new book, Fifty Is the New Fifty: Ten Life Lessons for Women in Second Adulthood offers insight and practical advice to women on the challenges and unexpected rewards of being 50+.
50 is the new 50 book giveawayI spent most of my childhood and early adulthood behaving properly. My goal in life was to make people like me, to do what was expected of me, to measure up. That means getting good grades, being popular, and fortunately in the case of my family, also doing good work. So it wasn't all bad.

But as I reached this wonderful stage of life that I call Second Adulthood, I came to the dawning realization that I didn't need to have everybody like me. I didn't need to say yes all the time, and, in fact, the only way that I could be an authentic person was if I began to figure out what I wanted to say yes and no to. And saying no, I quickly realized, involved sometimes making people mad. For me, the whole process of saying no, talking back, and standing up for what I think has been the theme and personality of this new stage of life.

Every woman 50+ that I have interviewed in my work has said to me, "You know, I just don't care what people think anymore. And of course, what they really mean is they do care what other people think--but they care more what they think." It's a big part of what's so much fun about this stage in our lives. I call it the "F--- You 50s!"

Learning to say "no" has affected my life in so many ways. Some examples:

  • Marriage

    When you feel that you can't say no, your modus operandi is to be manipulative, to hint, to try and wheedle things that you want or wheedle your way out of things that you don't want. To step up and use two letters where you were using 20 paragraphs, is very refreshing. In my case, it was very refreshing for my husband too!
  • Work

    My first adulthood was spent in an office as a magazine editor (for Ms. Magazine and the Columbia Journalism Review), where I used my manipulative wheedling skills to great effect. I felt my role was to clarify and organize and give power to other people's ideas an opinions, and I loved that. I loved editing. Until I began writing, in my 50s, I had no motivation to write, because I thought I really didn't know anything, and I didn't have any opinions.

    But as I found my voice as a woman, and as I found my nos and yeses, I began to think that I had something to say. I've now written three books, and in each one, my sense of authority--not superiority, but a sense that I had something that I wanted people to listen to--has grown. It's very exhilarating.
  • Cancelling appointments

    I'd always been grateful when other people cancelled appointments with me; it was like found time. But until I turned 50, I never thought of creating that found time for myself. I'm not talking about being rude and standing people up. I mean what doctors do all the time, simply say, "I'm sorry, I have to change the appointment"--or better yet, just scratch something off your calendar and not replace it. What a gift!
  • Friendship

    Every woman I've ever talked to who has gone through bad times or who has wondered whether she could really dare to do something has said to me, "I could not have done it without my friends." Women need this circle of trust, so that when hard things happen we can laugh together. There are countless ways that a real good circle of friends is important, and we learn to appreciate them more and more as we get older.

    That said, as we enter this new phase many of us realize there is a category of friends from our old life that are dragging us down. They say, "That's not like you. What's the matter with you?" or "Why are you being so selfish?" Those are the people that you really want to separate yourself from.
  • Adult children

    As children leave the nest some women feel lost, lonely and useless--but at least as many women say, "Whoopee!" They think, "Now I can turn that room into a study for myself; now I don't have to be sitting by the door at 1 and 2 o'clock; now I can shave both legs on the same day." Suddenly we have more opportunity to shape our time and our days than we've had in a long time, and I think that propels many of us into a lot of new adventures.

    This can create conflict when the kids decide to come back home. I've heard some women say, "Oh God, I'll have to change the locks!" Luckily, the more we learn to do unto ourselves as we have been doing unto others, the more we can hold our own with those kinds of demands.
  • Caregiving

    Aging parents are a real responsibility and one that has fallen predominantly on women, whether it's her parents or her husband's parents. Women tend do everything they can to make old age comfortable for relatives. And that can deplete your newfound energy; it can force you to give up a job. This is a societal issue that we need to address: how to care for one another and how we support caretakers.

    Saying no isn't easy in this case, but you can say, "I need help." I urge friends in this situation to acknowledge that they are not enough, and to reach out to the many people and organizations that can offer you support. I know an organization in California that raises money to give full-time caretakers a week off to go on a cruise. They not only pay for the cruise, but they pay for the replacement nursing caretaking services. You can't walk away from your role as a caregiver, but you can protect yourself so that it doesn't consume your life.

How has learning to say "no" changed your life? Join the conversation below. The first ten members to post will win a FREE COPY of Suzanne's new book!

responses (26)

kanmko said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

Yes, saying No can be good for your health and others also. It is good if you can do it gracefully. Right now, I will have to say no to a friend, so I do not end up enabling her to do things that I do not agree with. I am waiting to see if it will be necessary. Not too long though. Patience and love make a good mix when you are learning to say no.

debsmr said to kanmko
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

    Learning to say no without feeling guilty is very empowering and freeing. Learning that we have the right to pick and choose what we want to say no to is an important lesson. It gives us the ability to say yes to those things we truly want to do, to have time for ourselves, to learn who we are.  If we don't learn to say no - we spend all our time pleasing others and losing ourselves.

JiggityJig said to debsmr
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

It's interesting that in my second adulthood, I have had to learn to say "no" to myself. I have discovered, even though I've managed to accomplish many things in my first adulthood, that I have been afraid that structure and routine would take away from the life that I want. I was afraid that discipline would limit me rather than free me. In my second adulthood I've learned to set goals - both long term and short term. In my second adulthood I've learned to say "no" to many of my impulses and "yes" to the artful discipline that gleans the rewards that I have chosen in new and live-giving ways.  

Steele said to JiggityJig
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

The funny thing is, I have learned over the years to say "No" to myself more than anyone else.  "No, you can't afford those shoes" or "No, you really should be doing something else, like cleaning the house."  Now that I am in my 50's, I am beginning to realize that I can use the process of give and take a little more liberally.  I CAN say no to my friends and family when they are asking too much of me.  But I can also say yes to mySelf.  I deserve it!

RB said to JiggityJig
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

In the last ten years I have been married divorce, broken out of toxic relationship moved six times, and came down with a few health issues. Lerning to say no was paramount to coping in the changes with others. In my second adulthood which I really get (now 57) I am taking the learned knowledge and improving my life and the woman I am/want to be. Discipline means to teach so before buying I ask myself about purchases, before entering into a relationships I ask myself is this the man one who is whole could I be happy with him or he me? These things have helped me control impluse buying and not enter into other toxic relationships. I met a great guy online in Cal I am in Pa. the more we talked..he started becoming controling and demanding of my time and me. The sex talk was all anal which I am no prude but did not sit right with me as it was all he seemed interested in. I am learning and know the best of my life is yet to come. One day at a time. I volunteer in two organizations and really enjoy life without a man and/or others as I once needed. Shalom to all...Rebecca

mkpelland said to kanmko
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

I'm 59 - I learned to say no several years ago when a series of family crises, from Alzheimers to a son in Iraq to a daughter assaulted by her Navy supervisors to my husband being seriously ill, delpleted me until I ended up in the hospital with weird, but thank God, not serious symptoms. Some really compassionate nurses came to talk to me in my hospital bed and helped me understand that I could shorten my own life by trying to make everyone else's perfect.

I still have occasional trouble setting boundaries with my grown kids - I feel like my job description includes rescue. But I'm getting there. Nicely. I encourage all women to take stock of their energy levels and learn to give what you are able to, but keep in mind that you must keep a deep reserve for self.

I posted my response here because the interface to post it on the original article didnt work this morning.

mkp

www.womendaybyday.com

salreardon said to mkpelland
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

It took me awhile to learn to say no but now that I have found the courage to do so, I am much much more happier with myself. I was in a toxic marriage that wasn't good for me. I was too much the enabler for him.  I still have some problems saying no to things at work but that is not always a bad thing.

Marilyn - VN Staff said to mkpelland
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

mkp, thank you for letting us know about the technical glitch. We're investigating the problem now.

Barb said to mkpelland
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

I too feel that I learned how to say no to people and demands during my husband's prolonged illness and death.  I also learned how to ask for help and accept it gratefully.  But as I've gotten older--I'm 60 now--it's been interesting to start seeing how older women are automatically assumed to be available not only in terms of time but also in terms of being sort of a Giving Tree (the true insidiousness of that message is all too clear now) to everyone who wants an ear, a support, a cheerleader.  As a teacher, parent, colleague, friend--I'm frequently surprised by how people, even ones who've known me for years--seem to think I've given up my own goals, preferences, and private time to participate in their events or activities.  I'm also lucky to have many friends, especially among younger colleagues and their families, who still seem to see me as the person I've always been.  But I find myself frequently frustrated by expectations that aging means one no longer has an independent life.  Sometimes it's hard to maintain a sense of humor about it all and even with my daughter, I sometimes find myself in disagreements about how we are to relate.

I don't think this is all bad; in fact, it's kind of reassuring to know that every decade (maybe every year) brings changes and opportunities that require negotiation regarding our roles and commitments.  But it is sometimes painful, too, for ordinary assertiveness and a belief that my time and values are truly my own and are to be used to bring me happiness and satisifaction. 

I recently posted a poem by Mary Oliver called The Journey in which a woman leaves her home during a storm, feeling the hands of others gripping her ankles and crying "Save me!" but she keeps on walking into the windy night, until she can hear at last that tiny voice inside her own life, urging her on "to save the only life" she can save--her own.  I read that poem like a personal mantra as a young wife and mother, and now I'm returning to it again!

Marilyn - VN Staff said to mkpelland
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

mkp, the problem you reported this morning has been fixed. Thanks again for letting us know so we could fix it right away.

emad57 said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

I still find it hard to say no.  Maybe it's because I'm a Nurse and I have spent a lifetime caring for others.  Maybe it's because I still find it hard to have people mad at me.  I don't know.

I find it's most difficult at work.  I still try to do everything for everybody but in our health care system it's no longer possible.  That's where it's the toughest for me.  Maybe that's a good thing because for the first time I find myself having to say no.  Mind you, I never had that problem at work in my younger years.  Of course actual time was not an issue in those days.  The issue was when I disagreed with the decisions of others - especially Doctors.  I remember one incident in particular when I refused to send my patient to surgery.  I felt the Respiratory Technologist and myself could wean this 100 year old patient off the ventilator rather than forcing him to have a tracheostomy.  I stood alone before that bed and said no - you won't take him to surgery.  I had the entire surgical team come to my patient's bedside ready to push me out of the way - threatening to report me.  Finally the Anesthetist came forward and said I was right and she would take responsibility.  The RT and I weaned that patient off the ventilator that day.  He never needed surgery.  He never had surgery.  He was a 100 year old business man who still ran his own business but had nobody to speak for him but me.  It was hard to stand strong against the kind of power that a Thoracic Surgeon and the entire surgical team yielded.  I did that sort of thing all the time.  I find it harder these days.  Of course I've mellowed a lot and I still stand to protect my patients when I don't agree with a decision - it's just harder for some reason.  It's equally important today as it was then - just harder.  Maybe someone can explain to me why that is. 

I have made decisions this year though just for me.  These decisions are unpopular with others I know and even people I don't know have made sarcastic remarks to me but they make me happy.  That's a first for me.  Maybe that's my first baby step.  What do you think?

 

LMLedford said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

I am totally embracing my 50th birthday this year.  I am excited and eager to step in to this new chapter of my life.  I am striving for balance with saying No to certain things - I am finding out that I want to do way too much and it's taxing on me and my family.  I am ready to find that balance and know that the Universe will provide me the perfect outlet for me. 

lajek said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

Learning to say "No" is a continuing lesson for me.  I live with major serious chronic health problems, which means "No" is a regular part of every day.  This is the major theme of my life since turning 50.  Fortunately, I, like so many others, find that doing what takes care of me is much more important than what others think.  Of course, this has changed my relationship with others, but most importantly, it signals a change with me!  I'm now much more authentic than ever before!

JeannieM said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

Thank You to Everyone's responses to this! I am enjoying being able to read that other people are feeling what I have been noticing lately.  I am just beginning to understand the Freedom and Surprise of saying NO. It was not something I have ever been good at and I actually find myself giggling a little when I say No - and realize it doesn't matter if everyone agrees with me! I am also finding that I no longer wish I were younger. I LIKE this new found Freedom and plan to keep it!  I am looking forward to reading your book Suzanne! Thank You!

Julie_G said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

As a child, I was never allowed to say no. Not for any reason. As so many women do, I carried that with me even after I grew up. Now that I've turned 50, I find myself finally realizing that I AM an adult now, my life is my own, and I have the right to control it. I still feel a twinge sometimes when I have to say no, but I'm working on getting over it. Saying no isn't mean or selfish. In fact, I've realized that the people who call you "selfish" are usually only saying that because they aren't getting what they want - so who's really being selfish here?

creampuff123 said to Julie_G
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

I, too, wasn't allowed to say "no" while growing. I grew up with "what will people think?" and was given the message that it was my job to please everyone else. It took a nervous breakdown in my mid 50's to learn I could say "no" to my mother,,,,and others. It has been a very hard journey to undo that mentality but I'm finally can say that I love the person that I am, just as I am and I can say "no" and not feel guilty anymore. So many wasted years!!!! but better late than never!

Pixie said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

"No way I will do it my way thank you."  Heard, but did not listen to the friends and relatives who thought they knew what was best for Pixie.  I listened to my inner voice.  Diagnosed with Multiple Sclerosis at age 32 then widowed at 45 after 25 years of marriage.  Not following my original life plan, so on to plan "B."  Sold my house and went to Mexico and was cured (yes-CURED) of Multiple Sclerosis.  Given a new life is incredible.  I have done so many things that I never dreamt of.  The 50s are truely fabulous.

texasrose said to Pixie
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

Pixie, where did you go in Mexico? I will pass the information on to a friend.  Thanks!

kgritts said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

Wow! Learning to say "no" is a liberating experience. I can't say that I have completely mastered it with no guilt - but I sure am working on it. My husband has a little saying, "you can only do what you can do!" and it is sooo true! I am learning, at 51, to look at my life as mine. I had always looked at it as "daughter, wife, mother, friend." A few months ago, I lost my mother and it really made me think about who SHE was. In looking through her things, I came to see her as not just my mother, but as a young woman starting out with dreams and ambitions, as a wife and mother, yes, but also at her, just her. Her talents, her gifts, her LIFE! I don't want to live as someone else's idea of someone but as some ONE! Some ONE with needs, desires, and gifts - not just a person meeting other's expectations.

Linda1 said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

After I reached 50 I decided that I'd said yes to far too many things.  Now at 60 it's even more clear.  I always check in with myself to see if I really want to or need to do anything that is requested of me.  Do I really have energy for that, does doing this allow the other person to not take responsibility, etc.  Girls should read this when they are young.  When you say yes too much your health can definitely become an issue.

Gail said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

When I turned 50, 5 years ago! in fun, I recall saying to friends, "I'm 50 now, I can do whatever I want"!  One of those things was learning to say no, but with a positive tone (not wanting to hurt/offend anyone) But, more so, being able to say no and not feeling the need to explain why (unless of course, it truly deserved an explanation) . .that was freeing.  In turn, I also learned to respect and accept others that would say no to me on the occasion they felt it necessary to do so. . .without questioning why.

 

Gail 

Traci said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

I have enjoyed reading all the responses.  I have struggled with saying no to others, but in the last few years---I have finally gotton better at saying no to others and yes for myself, at least some of the times.............I will keep practicing........

joesgirl said to Traci
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

When I had to say no to my own children and take care of myself and my marriage, that was a life change for me.  I had been a caregiver for my daughter who suffers with MS and her daughter who has Bipolar for 13 years. Not that I turned my back on them, I just started to make some better decisions for me and my husband.  My health was suffering, as well as my marriage. Then, my son comes forward and gives up his single life and says he wants to do it for us!  He has had them since Aug.08!  It has worked out so good for us!!

Donna

pattig said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

WHAT A CONCEPT!! Just say no!???  My family would fall over in their tracks...!!!  I have read all the comments and agree completely that we should be able to take control/take charge, I just have a difficult time doing in by saying just 'yes' or just 'no'.  I am pretty good about always telling my husband to go play golf - anytime, anywhere! - that's the found time concept!!! lol!  I suppose we all just work along and do the best we can!  It comes to us when we are ready for it!

DianeW said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

I am 62 years old and a widow of 4 years.  I am learning that saying no is ok and also to let others know when their behavior is acceptable towards me, ie. standing me up!  I was raised to follow the rules and also cooperate and be a good girl.  I have learned you can still be a "good person" by thinking of myself more.  I am looking forward to reading this book.  

nangano said to Suzanne Braun Levine
undefined method `created_at' for nil:NilClass
new!

In many ways I lived your life.  I did a few rebellious things when I was young, but for reasons I won't go into.  My parents placed a great deal of responsibility on me with my younger siblings.  Eventually it got out of hand.  I became caregiver for life.  Whenever problems arose, I gave my all, even to the point of raising my youngest sister's two children after I was fifty years old. 

When times were good for me, I shared my meager wealth or experience.  I built them homes that reaped them great profits or found investments that brought great returns.  When times were tough for them I helped iny way I could. 

But when times were tough for me, it was not reciprocated.  One sibling did help, but the rest didn't.  There were always excuses or absolute silence.  Finally, I had enough.  When an illness hit me hard,  lost my business and the children I was raising hurt me deeply, I had had enough.  I was always ridiculed for being the "straight one", the "nerd".  Or when I had failures, ridiculed.  It was never enough.

Finally, I found my voice.  I spoke my piece and said that it was time for me to think of myself and what was best for my husband and I.  In this time of economic stress and strain one must downsize.  Prioritize your life and eliminate the baggage.

I've never been good at being selfish or turning my back on family, but you can only take so much.  It felt good to say, enough!  In Italian there is a great word that can be said with exhilarating emphasis: BASTA!

Well, BASTA!  Don't judge me, don't ridicule me and don't ask me for another favor.  There's no more left.  The emotional bank is depleted.  I think I surprised the hell out of the family. 

I once made a promise to my mother before she died at a young age from cancer.  Well, mom, I tried.  But when a ship is sinking there's a time to jump off.  We're still a family, we still fight, but I'm not struggling to hold it together.  We either sink or swim.  Love me or leave me alone.

BASTA!

1 member loves this!
Pure and Natural