Vibrant Nation

giving back

Why would you choose to help animals instead of people?
posted 07/31/2009, 06:24PM new!

Working in animal rescue, we are often asked: "Why are you helping animals? Why aren't you helping people?" But the truth is, when you help animals, you are always also helping people.

People tend to assume that if an animal is in a shelter, the problem is with the animal. Most of the time, this simply isn't true. These animals are not difficult or sick; the fact that their humans have problems is what creates problems for the animals. Whenever a human being has a serious problem such as illness, bereavement, job loss, or divorce, you will often find an animal suffering at the end of it. So you never help an animal without also helping a person.

A woman once contacted our organization, Best Friends, to ask if we could take her dog. She had cancer and several small children. She was terrified, exhausted and overwhelmed. Amidst all this, she had a dog and she was feeling bad because she couldn't give the dog enough exercise. So she felt she needed to place the dog with us.

This woman and I talked for a long time. I listened to her describe her situation. Eventually I said, "Your children are stressed because you're sick, but they will feel even more stressed by losing the family pet at the same time." I suggested she find a girl scout or neighbor willing to walk the dog. I also reminded her that dogs are fundamentally loyal animals. If her dog didn't get exercise for a period because she was getting treated for cancer--well, that dog was part of the family. Families go through rough times together, and the dog would surely prefer to give up exercise temporarily rather than be separated from its family permanently. You don't split up a family simply because times are hard!

By then the woman was sobbing. She said, "Do you think it would really be okay to keep my dog?" The woman didn't want to give up her dog at all; she wanted to do the right thing, but she had been missing the point. I find that many people are well-meaning when it comes to animals, but they often make wrong choices like giving up a pet or buying pets from stores, misguidedly. At Best Friends, we try to engage and guide people, offering as much information and support as we can, so they can solve their problems rather than sacrifice the pets that they love.

Silva is our Vibrant Giver for August 2009. Follow this link to read her Vibrant Nation profile.

1 member loves this!

responses (3)

mscoach said to Silva Battista 07/31/2009, 06:24PM new!

I'm so happy this post is here. As an "animal person" who does spay neuter, feeds feral colonies, contributes to Best Friends and a couple of other animal rescue and education groups, I am often having similar conversations. I'd like to add another point and that is that our lives reflect the larger world. What we do for one species or being goes out in waves of energy to affect the greater mass of energy beings and energy in the world. 

Not to mention, we should follow our hearts and do the work we are called to do. Some may want to work with children or returning vets, other's feel drawn to animal rescue or veterinary medicine. One is not better or more "right" than the other, simply people's hearts finding and following their passions. I believe that there are enough givers in the world that everything we share the planet with can be supported if we see the love behind someone's actions and not try to find the "what's wrong here."

 

Sheltiemum said to Silva Battista 07/31/2009, 06:24PM new!
I worked in Sheltie rescue for 10 years and I absolutely agree with everything that both you and mscoach said.  I would say that 97 percent of the time, the dog is fine.  Just look at Michael Vick's rescued dogs!  My husband and I still take in "emergency" foster dogs, and, once they get out of the bad situation, they want to give and get love just like anybody else.  Congratulations, Silva, on being the August Vibrant Giver!
Tali said to Silva Battista 07/31/2009, 06:24PM new!

It always struck me that people who ask that question, "why help dogs (or animals) instead of people?" have a rather narrow vision. First, nothing stops anyone from helping both. Second, by helping animals we ARE helping people, since by educating people about the need to help animals we are also helping create better, more compassionate and responsible people. Of course, the most obvious answer is that animals are not lesser beings than people and deserve help equally. 

I am a former college professor who has switched to teaching at an inner-city high school for the last 10 years.  I have seen how much of a difference it makes in my students when they learn to help animals, when they research the different animal-rescue issues, and what they learn in the debates about the issues that are part of my class (I teach English and Literature, and use essays and articles about animal abuse, dog-fighting, animal rescue, etc. in discussions about ethics in our society).  Best Friends (online and the magazine I get when I send donations) is one of the on-line sources I use every year.

Pure and Natural