Vibrant Nation

health & fitness

NancyB's avatar
from
NancyB
plantar fasciitis
posted 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Has anyone had planter fasciitis in both heels and what was your recovery time?

responses (66)

Beach Bum said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

My pain was more in my right heel than the left.  After stretching and icing for 9 months, I decided to have the cortizone injection.  I had immediate relief.  I still feel some pain at times, but on a 1-10 scale, it's at a 1 now.  The Podiatrist explained the injection clears up the inflammation, thus reducing the pain.

Spirit seeker said to Beach Bum 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

What many doctors fail to explain is that cortizone shots can actually cause joint damage.  There is a shot with a product called Traumeel which has no side effects other than pain relief.

Besides Dr. Scholls heel cushions there are "heel seats" on the market called HTP heel seats, which my daughter has found very helpful for her foot issues.

Also for those with PF: Its helpful to work with a massage therapist or physical therapist to learn not only how to massage & stretch the calf muscles as well as the feet, plus learn exercises to help as well.

 

Plantar Fasciitis Self-care

Acute Stage
Rest, with no weight bearing if the pain is severe, ice and elevate the affected foot as much as possible.

Chronic Stage
Rest from aggravating activities.  Return to activity is gradual, beginning with non-weight-bearing activities such as swimming or bicycling.  

Massage and stretch foot & calf before first rising in the morning or if you have been sitting for a while.  Heat is applied to the calf before activities that cause pain.

Ice is applied three or four times per day to control the inflammation and after activities that cause pain.  One method of icing is to fill a plastic soda bottle with water and freeze it and to place the sore area on the bottle for at least 10 minutes. All air and some of the water needs to be squeezed out of the bottle before closing the cap and freezing.

Check shoe size or change to the next size up.  New Balance has adequate support and flexibility.  Orthotics or heel cups might help.   Consider going to a physical therapist for ultrasound treatments and supportive taping.

Sometimes heavy bedding or tightly tucked in bottom sheets cause the foot to plantar flex at night.  If night time plantar flexion is a contributor to the problem, and taking heavy bedding off feet or loosening the sheets doesn’t help, a nighttime brace can be prescribed.  

1 member loves this!
Spirit seeker said to Spirit seeker 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

And the other thing I forgot to mention is that your footwear is crucial.  Do not wear flipflops, as the more the toes have to work to grip the sandals the more problems it will cause - as your muscles will be working overtime.  If you're going to wear sandals make sure you wear the type with straps to hold them on your feet, such as Tevas or Keen, etc.

If you're going to wear shoes go for the comfortable & supportive footbed of Merrells, Born, Keen, New Balance, etc. as they will be better options for those with foot problems.

 

Exercises

Toe Taps.  Keep the heel on the floor and lift all of the toes off the floor.  Tap only the big toe to the floor while keeping the outside four toes in the air.  Next, keep the big toe in the air and tap the other four toes to the floor.
To stretch the plantar fascia, stand, facing a wall.  With the heel on the floor, the toes and the heads of the metatarsals rest against the wall.  By dorsiflex the ankle by bringing the knee towards the wall, the toes are extended, stretching the plantar fascia.  Gastrocnemius and soleus (calf muscles) should also be stretched while doing this.

The intrinsic muscles of the feet are strengthened by scrunching up a towel or picking up pencils with toes.

 

Consult your physician, a physical therapist, or a medical massage therapist for more suggestions. especially those trained in sports medicine for more exercises. 

Massage Therapists are often trained in techniques which can be of help as well.  Look for Active Isolated Stretching, Active Release Therapy, Myofascial Release work, Rolfing or KMI modalities.  Generally speaking you will not find this type of practitioner in the spa settings, but will need to look for individual Massage practitioners who have taken additional training in these techniques

1 member loves this!
Emily Slonina said to Spirit seeker 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I am a Trager Neuromuscular Re-Education Practitioner and Trager has worked very well with my clients as it re-educates you on how you stand, sit and use your feet.  As a yoga teacher, I also recommend yoga sandals (unlike flip flops) they make you spread all your toes.  Go to www.yogasandals.com and check out what the Osteopathy Doctors say about them.  For more info on Trager, see my website www.lotushealingvillage.com and www.tragerus.org. Good luck! namaste, Emily

1 member loves this!
Spirit seeker said to Emily Slonina 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Thanks for the reply Emily,  I've been a massage therapist & energy worker for approx. 20 years in Bucks County PA.  I'm currently working on my website too, though if anyone is interested in more info they can find me via web search:

Deborah Engisch-Platt

Riversong Massage & Energetic Healing Arts

Point Pleasant, PA.

Olga said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Mine was just in the right heel. I did stretching exercises and used heel cushions (Dr. Scholl's) in my shoes, especially in flatter shoes. It took about 6 mo. for recovery, but it was steady.

susanadele said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I had it on one foot, and it took about 18 months to heal. What worked best for me was wearing a night splint.  I think if I had found out about that earlier, I would have healed sooner.  It took a little getting used to, but it really helped.  Here's a link to an example of one.

http://www.amazon.com/Swede-O-Plantar-Fasciitis-Night-Splint/dp/B000636QAE

kanmko said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Glad to hear you were able to heal.

Charlotte from New Mexico said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Yes, had it in one heel only though.  I had surgery and was up and about that day.  I did make the mistake of overdoing it on day two.  I felt well enough, but was on my feet too long and had lots of pain and swelling.  I started  a new job in a different city two weeks post op.  I had to wear flats (the doctor wanted me in sneakers).  I wore the athletic shoes at home only.  Recovery took some time.  I would say a good four weeks to feel recovered.  I would want to mention that I didn't wear heels for a year after the surgery.  But I have not had a bit of trouble since!

NancyB said to Charlotte from New Mexico 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Charlotte...My podiatrist recommended surgery also when it was in my left heel, but I held out and now it's been 1 yr. and it's a lot better (still there though).  As of Jan. of this year now it's in my right heel and arch...did corizone shot,been sleep in night splints, icing, stretching, and of course have custom orthotics since last July.  Just don't think I can go another year for this foot to get better.  Having another procedure first called "dry needling", and then surgery will be  next on my list.  My podiatrist doesn't do this , but his partner does and it is non-invasive, but has great results. Have my appt. on Monday, March lst. Wish me luck!!!

Spirit seeker said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Hi NancyB,

Just checking in to find out how you made out with this treatment?  Hope you're feeling better now!

10felines said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I had PF on my right foot first and used a night splint and eventually cortizone shots.  Wow was that painful in the heel but the PF pain subsided for a while.  Eventually I need the shots more and more often and surgery was recommended.  Since the surgery I have not had the pain but my foot swells everyday now.  I also found out I had a stress fracture on the top of my foot soon after surgery.  I wondered if they did that during surgery???  Anyway, soon after my somewhat disappointing surgery I developed it in the other foot.  I went to another doctor and he had me buy some very expensive athletic shoes.  No good.  Did some more stuff but got no where.  One day I saw a woman with these funny shoes and asked her about them.  They were Z-Coils and they have fixed my feet!  Not one of the 3-4 docs I went to mentioned these and they are the thing that kept me from pain and more surgery.  So that is my recommendation....Z-Coils.  Expensive and funny looking but pain free feet are well worth it.  Wish I had tried them before all of the other expense and hassles and pain. 

Charlotte from New Mexico said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Nancy, I hope that the more conservative route works.  I treated conservatively for over a year with injections, foot gear and anti-inflammatory meds.  I just had to do something.  I hear that the procedures that they do now are not as invasive as what I had 15 years ago.

NancyB said to Charlotte from New Mexico 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Charlotte,  well podiatrist said that I wasn't a candidate for this type conservative treatment and that surgery is still the best way to go.  I keep thinking that I can wear this thing out, but it's wearing me out...going on over a year now. Can you remember how long it took you to recouperate from your surgery? Also, after, can you get in other shoes other than tennis shoes, like to get to church, etc. I can get in sketchers biker shoes with my orthotics, but just an hour and then out of them.

NancyB said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Charlotte,  Sorry I didn't see your reply about recouperation time that you had posted before so thanks so much.

10felines said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Don't do surgery!!!!  GEt Z-Coil shoes.  Wonderful!

susanadele said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I just remembered that another thing that really helped was custom orthotics.  I had this problem years ago, and I still wear the same orthotics with most shoes, including when I run.  Havent had a reoccurence of plantar faciitis.

JudyH said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I woke up one more three years ago with plantar faciitis in both feet.  Thought I was going to loose my mind.  Use night boot, did exercises, wore Earth shoes and no heels.  I insoles I wear with all shoes and have not been able to wear heels but weggie adn plantform shoes work nicely.  Did get in a pair of 2 inch dresses ankle boots this year with my insoles and felt really good. 

Have no pain anymore.  Arch sometimes becomes sore if I go too many days wearing flip flops or thongs. 

LLG said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

There is a very simple "exercise" that can be done.  It is more like a physical therapy fix.  Before getting out of bed in the morning, flex you foot, bend your toes up all the way and find the long muscle (that should be firm now) and press with your thumb.  This muscle runs the length of your foot, press on it just at the metatarcle...hold that pressure for 5 seconds. Repeat 5 times then go to the other foot if required.  This has helped both myself and with my daughter with the pain. It is truly remarkable.

Beverley K. said to LLG 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Could you explain in a little more detail where you are pressing with your thumb?  Is that on the front or back of the foot? 

LLG said to Beverley K. 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

press with your thumb just below the joint below the big toe...there's the big toe, then the "pad" below the big toe, then the muscle should extend a bit once you pull your toes backward.....there and that long stringy muscle press firmly....it really works!

LLG said to Beverley K. 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

press with your thumb just below the joint below the big toe...there's the big toe, then the "pad" below the big toe, then the muscle should extend a bit once you pull your toes backward.....there and that long stringy muscle press firmly....it really works!

sephillips said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I had plantar faciitis a few years ago.  After trying heal pads, night boots (couldn't sleep w/it) and arch supports but what really helped the most was switching to good quality footwear with built in arch support. While no longer fashionable, the Birkenstock sandals w/HIGH ARCH support helped the most.  I don't remember how long it took...about a year of so...it disappeared and has not returned.

Good Luck!

Anita E said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Sounds odd but you might consider a chiropractor.  I was training for the 60 mile Breast Cancer walk in Dallas.  Between letting my shoes wear to thin lots of additional miles and twisting an ankle and falling.  I had pain in my foot for months.  This was up the side of my ankle.  I was told I had tendinitis.  Weeks of icing, resting, and anti-inflammatories.  No change.  I decided to try a Chiropractor and in one visit he relieved the pain.  My hips were out and my ankle was jammed.  I still have a bit of aching, I can walk again and work out.  Wasn't possible before, a trip to the mail box was misery.  It might be worth a try.    

Karen1 said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I had repeated occurences of plantar faciitis in both feet. I lost an excellent job that took me years to reach that level of income.This could have been prevented. Years later, my doctor did a "Bone Density"  test. My bone density was below the normal level, there are bones in the feet.  Low Bone Density is a sign of Osteoporosis. I was in my early 50s.THE OLDER WE GET, THE LOWER OUR BONE DENSITY BECOME. I was prescribed "ACTENOL" and told to take "CALTRATE" that has "calcium &  vitamin D". Both of these items strengthen bone density. After one year, I am physically stronger  thruout my whole body. It is amazing! I can climb stairs all day... walk for long periods of time & do my daily activities without weakness. I have not had a reocurrence of plantar faciitis. Oh! I wear my orthotics to support the arch of my feet too.  Hope this information helps! 

1 member loves this!
Spirit seeker said to Karen1 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Low bone density can often be helped by weight bearing exercises, so research & talk with your physician.  It's not all about prescription medications!

Part of the problem is related to poor dietary choices we've all made along the way.  Not many people realize that carbonated beverages leach calcium out of our bones, and the excess sugar we take in creates inflammation.  Inflammation is a major problem as it is an underlaying cause of our aches & pains, arthritus, cancer & heart disease & more.  It's a vicious circle!  While Vit. D & calcium are a great combination the form we take it in matters a great deal. Plus we actually need more Magnesium than we do Calcium!

Some forms of calcium are not always well-absorbed, and we can even get to much of it!  The dairy industry has always promoted calcium to sell their products. And the RDAs put out by the government were based on studies done years ago by the government to provide minimum levels of various vitamin & mineral levels ~ for MEN.  Our needs as women are different & vary depending our age & heath conditions. 

An excellant resource on nutritional information for various health issues is The Prescription for Nutritional Healing by Balch & Balch.

Products I take for bones & muscles, as well as the nervous system:

Magnesium Calm & Calm Plus Calcium both from Peter Gillham's Natural Vitality  www.petergillham.com

Osteo Herb (Supports Healthy Bone Structure) from Herbalist & Alchemist

www.herbalist-alchemist.com

For Inflammation:

Zyflamend PM by New Chapter is an excellant formula & it contains some extra ingredients which are very calming to the mental, emotional states as well.

 

Hopefully others will post what they take & why, as well as giving other helpful resource info. too - as the more we share here the better!

MrsB said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

My plantar faciitis went away. I wear arch supports in my sneakers and dress shoes (bought mine at Wal-mart for about $7) and I have never had a problem since. I have a high instep and never wear shoes with a hel height of more than 1". Plantar Faciitis has to be one of the most painful conditions I've ever had and am pleased that the condition is not a life sentence of pain.

Cindy Lee said to susanadele 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I had custom orthotics made and it seemed that my pain/discomfort was gone almost immediately.  I did dance at my niece's wedding barefoot and was I sorry the next several days.  I have had back surgery and have been wearing Skecher's Shape-Up's with the orthotics and this helps both my back discomfort and the plantar facitis.  The Skechers are like having an anti-fatigue mat with you everywhere you are going or standing.

MrsB said to Cindy Lee 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

My friend also purchase the Skecher's Shape-Up's and swears by them for easing her hip pain. she recently went through hip surgery and said they are very comfortable to walk in, though I notice her balance standing up on them is rather odd. Kind of a rocking motion. I tried a pair on at JC Penney and they were novel but I prefer Saucony as they are narrow in the heel.

Jilla said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I have had plantar fasciitis several times.  The first time I had it I was on crutches, took anti-inflammatories.  I didn't properly heal until went to an orthopedic who prescribed that I wear a walking boot that went almost up to my knee.  It kept my foot stationary and I wore it for six weeks.  Afterwards, I had physical therapy for another six weeks, and also was fitted for orthotics. One of the things that I learned at physical therapy that helped with the pain was ice massage.  Get a paper cup and fill it with water, freeze.  Peel 1/4" inch at a time and massage foot with the ice.  It is more relaxing if you have someone else who can do that for you, but worked fine if you do it yourself.

Lin said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Several years ago, I had a terrible case of it in both feet. After about a year or so of extreme misery, I finally went to a prescriptive shoe store and was fitted with Swedish arch supports made of cork which I wore in my shoes. It was instant relief, but to heal the inflammation, I had to wear the supports in my shoes for the next year. I have been fine ever since, but now I always buy shoes that have arch supports built in so it doesn't come back.

NJ in AZ said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I used custom orthotics from a Foot Solutions store, stretching, ice, never walk around barefoot on hard surfaces and cherry pit extract supplement pills. It took about 6 months to be totally pain free. I never have even a twinge, now! I do wear good shoes as well. My new favorite work shoes are the Spira with springs in them.

CoachRuth said to NJ in AZ 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

<edited by moderator> - advertising

kanmko said to CoachRuth 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Hi CoachRuth,

I suffered injuries to both quads about a year ago, and things shifted to flair up previous injuries through out both of my legs. I've been healing with physical therapy, glucosomine and vitamins and would prefer not to use AIDs. How can I get a free sample of the Seaweed? Also, do you know anything about frankincense as an inflammatory?

lilmsnoitall said to NJ in AZ 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I love those shoes, and I will always have a pair as long as they keep making them.

nan said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Asa physical therapist that treats this condition every day, the biggest thing I have to recommend is making sure your footwear is adequate.  Proper arches, good support throughout, low heals. Cheap shoes just will not cut it.  Its tough in the summer, but no flip flops.  Stretching is key as well.  Some ultrasound therapy will help to speed along the recovery time as well, deep massage to help loosen up that tissue.  Cortisone shots can be a wonder, but iontophoresis from your physical therapist will work just as well for those of you that are needle-shy. 

1 member loves this!
marilyn13 said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

has anyone tried accupuncture?

 

Desiree529 said to marilyn13 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Yes I've tried acupuncture and it works!

kgb said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I understood from physical therapy that as the core weakens, commonly with age & women, posture changes & we pronate (walk more on the outside of the heel) which causes plantar fasciitis.  So, we need to strengthen the back side of our core: glutes and hamstrings.  Stretching can aggravate the pain, so do it, but be gentle.  There are so many good reasons to keep the core working.  We tend to think of core as only abdominals, but its also glutes and hams.  Good luck.

Ginger R said to kgb 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I had it in my right foot for about a year.  I was doing the exercises, ice etc.  My sister had it and discovered that if she wore SAS shoes the pain went away.  I tried it and it was a miracle.  I found tennis shoes to be the very worst shoes to wear when you  have this pain.   I wear SAS slip ons in the winter, I buy black and a dark tan/brown color and I buy sandles for the summer.  Not very sexy but at 62, I'll take comfort over sexy!  I limit any other dress shoes to just the bare minimum necessary when wearing a dress.  The pain in my foot is gone and I am so grateful.  Try buying SAS, they are expensive but well worth the money and they last forever.  The exercises that most described on this blog gave some relief also, as well as the ice.  I never need those anymore.  If my foot starts to feel like it is tightening up, I do massage it and I do the stretching. 

Cindy Lee said to kgb 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

That is why I'm thinking that my Sketcher Shape-ups with the custom made orthotics are doing so well for me.  The Shape-ups work the core, glutes and legs.  You have to start out slow with them tho cause they really do work those areas and people who just start out wearing them full time get sore.

kbt said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I have not had a problem since I started using good insoles such as Power Steps or Superfeet and I am running again.

MariK said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I'd had both heels in pain for almost 2 years...I tried exercises, stretches, heat, ice, massage, special expensive orthotics, shoes,  splints etc...nothing really helped. I'd gotten some relief with merril and born shoes with a slight heel, about 11/2 to 2 inches max but it was temporary. I could not walk barefoot or with sandals or flats of any kind...I teach nursing and when with students I am on my feet all the long day! This might seem far-fetched but I had to put two of my kids, who are in college in another city, on a gluten free diet for health reasons and I had to start it myself so that I could guide them with cooking....about three weeks into my new eating plan...with absolutely no wheat, barley, rye or oat products, I awoke one morning, got out of bed quickly and was astounded to find...about 7 feet from the bed...that I had ABSOLUTELY NO PAIN....that was amazing...I have continued with some stretching, a gluten free eating plan and most of my joint and muscle aches and pains (at 53 yo) are COMPLETELY GONE. We are all trully amazed...I think it had to do with the body's inflamatory responses...check it out. Have your doc's look into it.

MusicalMom said to MariK 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I think you are on to something as a source of a lot of mystery pains in our bodies.  While not a fanatic about it, there are certain foods that seem to not make me feel very good after I've eaten them.  I don't have any outright food allergies, but do have a few sensitivities.  

I've never liked pasta, pies, or cakes, and never been too much of a bread fan.  (I know - people think I'm weird - who could not like spaghetti?  Me!)  It might be my body telling me not to eat them. I also didn't like gravy, which most people love.  

I found a wonderful garbanzo bean gluten-free flour and had Hubby (the main cook in our house) try it.  As it turned out, there was only one unfortunate side-effect from using it - I like gravy now!  Ha! He made gravy with the GB flour one night, and it was the first time I can say that I really liked the gravy!  I normally never ate it.  Even though it is gluten-free, it makes a wonderful, creamy and tasty addition to whatever you add it to.  I am now looking into more gluten-free products. Note that the main offender is wheat.  Not all grains create gluten, so do not cut out all whole grains from your diet! Oats are still very good for you, for example.  

But, getting back to your statement about inflammatory responses - I think you are right on target.  Our bodies will tell us what they do and do not like if we listen.  Sometimes we do have to experiment to find out what that is, but it is worth it to find out.  I'd also suggest that almost anyone over 50 add a glucosamine/chondroitin supplement to their daily plan. We lose it as we get older, and wear and tear on the joints is a very real thing.   

laurjoan said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I had plantar fasciitis in both feet at the same time and it was very painful.  It felt like I was walking on hot coals all the time. I was sent for physical therapy and the first thing that was said was I was wearing the wrong type of shoes. I have high arches so orthotics were not recommended - they usually work far better for flat or low arch people.  I had to buy a pair of really good runners - Nike New Balance - at the time were $ 110.00.  I had always worn cheap shoes with not enough support and in my working days, lots of high heels. I had to go to physiotherapy for about a year, ice the bottom of my feet at least twice a day, only wear good support shoes, inside and outside.  it was a long year but finally the pain went away and now I am very careful of the shoes I wear and I still have those Nikes - its been about 4 years now so they turned out to be a real good buy! no flat shoes at all!  everyone can have a different remedy because of their particular feet. Mine was not just heels - it was explained to me that it is a main muscle that runs from the heel to the toes and it gets inflamed/stretched. heel supports didn't work for me and I tried different kinds.  I hope you have better success - at least not last a year. 

MrsB said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

The fastest and safest way to ease pain is to get arch supports for your shoes. As we age, our arches start to fall. If you become overweight (smile), that added weight tends to create this condition. Interestingly, arthritis in knee joints and hips is also often attributed to added poundage. After your feet start to feel better, try a walking program of say 15 min three times a week. The mall by our home has quite a following f folks who like to exercise where it's dry and safe. there are guards at the mall early before it opens, no traffic to deal with and there's a Jamba Juice by the parking area!

MusicalMom said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Yes!  

Now, let me preface this comment with the note that I am not selling anything, including my services, a disturbing trend popping up in the forums lately. No website to push, no product to sell. (I'm getting really tired of all the self-promotion on the forums! Not talking about things like favorite mascaras - I mean the outright selling!) I'm just passing along what my doc told me, and what actually worked. Also note that each person's feet can be so different (arches, toe problems, etc) that it would still be a good thing to go to a podiatrist for a checkup if you can possibly afford to go.

As a lifelong person with a preference for bare feet or flip flops, I often wore cheapie shoes for work or dressing up. After all, they were coming off as soon as I hit the door at home!  One day with no seeming reason, I had the worst pain in my feet I could stand.  It hurt like crazy to stand up.  Once I'd been up walking for a while it was better, but once I sat down, I'd better have a great reason to get back up, as the feeling of walking on thumbtacks was going to start all over again.

I am overweight, so often, that is the first thing doctors fling out as the cure for every possible thing - lose some weight and it'll feel better.  (Anyone else have that?  LOL!  I can have the same problems that athletes have, but in my case, it'll be because I am fat. *sigh*)  Anyway, after getting the "lose some more weight" response from my primary doc, I went to a podiatrist for help.  After all, I had not gained a thing since the previous week, but suddenly neither foot wanted to talk to me, and I was miserable. 

As it turned out, I had plantar fasciitis (sp?)(PF) and heel spurs in both feet. No wonder I hated standing up or getting up first thing in the morning!  The main tendon that runs along the bottom of the foot had become inflamed somehow, and both feet at the same time.  The tendon response is to tighten up, and you get the pain from that. The podiatrist suggested a pair of ill-fitting shoes was likely to blame.  (Me?  With my K-Mart specials?  Nah!)  

I can't say it was a quick fix, although I wish it was!  I was told to take ibuprofen for the pain, stop wearing flip flops and really cheap shoes, and to do some foot exercises.  He also gave me orthotic shoe inserts, which really took away a lot of the pain of the PF. I was not getting enough arch support in my shoes, even though I did not have a high arch. The heel spurs were a little harder to get over, and they still get irritated from time to time.  

Not once did the podiatrist suggest it was weight, by the way.  It is a foot problem that anyone of any age and any weight can get.  However, I didn't learn about a good way to help get over it and prevent it from recurring until my husband hurt his shoulder and was in physical therapy.  As I was waiting for him one day, one of the therapists there noticed me rolling my ankles (my attempt to keep circulation going).  When he asked what was wrong, I explained the PF and how my feet were aching that day.  He gave me the simplest thing to do at home (or anywhere) to help them - roll a GOLF BALL around under my feet!  

Yup - that is it.  Home physical therapy, and it works!  Just roll a golf ball around under your bare or be-socked feet for a few minutes a day (or whenever).  It helps to keep that tendon stretched out and lessens the chance of inflammation. It has been like a mini-miracle for me, anyway. I keep one under the computer desk at home, and roll it around while checking email, etc etc.  I can say that I have not had any problems with PF since I got better from that very first round with it. I no longer wear flip flops though - it's never quite been the same for me. I make sure that my shoes have support, and only wear New Balance or Reebok tennies now. No more $10 flat shoes!  ;  )

I hope that helps someone's feet feel better today!

suZannie said to MusicalMom 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Thanks that is well worth a try.  This is a wonderful source of ideas.   Our feet are so important and after watching my Mother suffer terribly at 85 with getting around physically and PF pain....I have decided that prevention is the best preparation I can do at my age of 65.    I have a genetic condition called Milroy's Disease, so anything I can do to assist my foot health the better.  The Golf Ball sounds logical to me and a good preventive measure as well as a treatment.   Love women helping women!!

10felines said to MusicalMom 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I use a rolling pin under my arch to massage it.  Feels wonderful and helps.   One of the few things the therapist said to do that worked!

MusicalMom said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

PS - Nancy, just saw one of your other posts where you mention that your doc is suggesting surgery. 
That seems a little drastic for PF.  While it might really be needed, I'd exhaust every other option.  PF can indeed recur, and you don't want to have to rely on a surgical fix each time.  I hope you'll try the golf ball from my previous post and see if it helps a little.  It took about a month to see noticable results, but I really have not had a recurrence (and have not lost any weight).  A simple golf ball might be your new best friend.

in2h2o said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Two years ago, I was suffering from this and had been for nearly a year.  It was getting worse fast.  My sister said that her husband had gone to his sports physician because he was suffering from it also.  He's 63, lives at Rocky Mountain National Parks door and regularly climbs three or four 14,000+ peaks in a day...so it doesn't occur from lack of excercise!

His physician told him to ice his feet by freezing a two-litter soda bottle with water and then rolling it under each foot applying pressure, while sitting down two or three times a day.  It actually feels good!  If it is too cold, wear socks until you become accustomed to the cold.

The second step was something I had never heard before and a brilliant idea for flexing your feet.  Sit down, stretch both legs out in front of you, feet together.  Form the capital letters of the alphabet as large as possible. Yes, all 26 of them with both feet at the same time without moving your legs.  Form each letter with maximum stretch and as big as possible without moving your legs.  Why the alphabet?  The alphabet flexes your feet in all directions, rather than just flexing them up and down and in circles. My sister is a registered nurse, so despite my skepticism, I gave it a try.

I did this several times a day.  It was difficult at first.  My feet gave out halfway through. But I rested a minute and continued where I left off. It is difficult in part because a big reason for plantar fasciitis occurring is that the muscles of the feet have tightened up. Kind of like the tightening of all muscles of our bodies as we age, causing us to me much less flexible.  By day three, I was able to get through the whole alphabet without stopping.

I was very skeptical because I had tried so many things with no success but she is a registered nurse, so I gave it a try.

It worked!  Within two weeks, my pain was completely gone!  No arch supports, no surgery, only a little flexing and some bottle-rolling. I was completely amazed that it worked because I had researched all possible methods of relief ad naseum on the internet..for a year!  I suspected, though, that I would be doing this for the rest of my life.  Not true!

I still stick my feet out occasionally and form the alphabet but to be honest, maybe once or twice a month.  I figure it can't hurt.  I had only one more episode, but at the first sign I started doing the alphabet, again.  It was gone within two days and I haven't had any further symptoms.

Give it a shot.  It's inexpensive (the cost of a two-liter bottle of soda) and minumum time investment.  Please post if it works for you because it still seems too good to be true and both my brother-in-law and I may have been the exception, but I really think the odds of that are unlikely.

I know how painful plantar faciitis can be so I hope all of you find relief.

~ barbara

1 member loves this!
Di Anderson said to in2h2o 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I'm 59 and had plantar fascitis for years.

I lost 60 pounds and wear Birkenstock shoes as much as possible; aerosoles or clarks to work. I wear a pair of heels once in a while. I don't walk a lot in the heels; maybe to church or to a business meeting. Learn to take care of your feet. Birkenstock shoes are wonderful. I recommend them to anyone who has foot problems. :)

kanmko said to in2h2o 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

When you say form the alphabet, do you mean write it in the air with the feet individually or curveboth of your feet to make the curves and lines of the alphabet?

I wrote the alphabet in the air. I'll give it a shot. I can do that anywhere

Thanks

basykes said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I suffered with plantar fasciitis for two years before I went to a podiatrist.  After trying over the counter orthotics, she finally prescribed custom orthotics.  I truly was pain-free in a week and have never had a problem again.  I took to wearing them all the time, even in my slippers.  I also bought the right shoes.  My sympathies go out to anybody suffering from this condition.  It's terrible!

Dorothy Sander said to basykes 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I only found relief after buying the correct shoes and wearing them all day, every day. When I did not have shoes on my feet I wore cushioning slippers but have to keep that to a minimum. I still have problems from time to time if I walk a lot or wear dress shoes, but I can keep it manageable by wearing the shoes I had properly fit by people who know the condition.

ekate said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Around Thanksgiving I had so much pain in my left heel I would limp every time I got out of the car. I went to CVS and bought insoles for all my shoes. The pain went away and I have not had any since that! How simple some solutions are! Hope you are all better by now. Good luck!

Lorraine76 said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I have a heel spur on my right heel. The inflammation was so bad I had to take prescription strength Ibuprofen for 30 days and stay off my feet. When it finally went away I used CUSHI HEELS and special heal inserts under them. I used the same system on both heels so my back wouldn't bee thrown off balance and cause pain.  All well and good, I had no problem for over a decade so I walk about 7 miles a week with no problem. Now here I am 51 years old and weigh 190 pounds on a good day and now my LEFT heel hurts. The inflammation is on the outside edge of my heel and it never goes away. I cut back my walking to one mile 2 times a week, and see the Podiatrist. The X-ray says I have a heel spur and it's transferring the pain to the edge of my heel.  I insisted on the very painful cortisone shot because I heard it gives almost immediate pain.  I admit it still hurt for a week but at a lesser degree. Finally it went all the way away, and only acts up slightly if I take those one and a half mile walks I prefer. Now I'm heavy and I NEED to walk! HA! I got more prescription strength Ibuprofen but take very little of it. Also the Dr. gave me these special ARCH supports and said to remove the heel cushions! He said if I had higher arch supports the pain would go away and stay away more or less. he also said to come back for another cortisone shot if I needed it. (I didn't).  Since I didn't want to spend $20.00 on some cheap looking arch supports for the Dr's. office I buy all my arch supports at Walmart for under $10.00. I have a wide foot and use Men's arch supports.

Spirit seeker said to Lorraine76 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Hi Lorraine,

I posted this awhile back - but it's very important for you to be aware that many doctors fail to explain that cortizone shots can actually cause deterioration of the injected joint, & that means permanent damage.  There is a shot with a product called Traumeel which has no side effects other than pain relief. 

ekate said to Spirit seeker 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

They sell Traumeel as a pill. I took it after a car accident since I didn't want to take presription drugs. You can buy it from www.isabellacatalog.com

It works! 

gypsylee said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Awful condition.  I got so depressed, thinking I would not be able to walk without pain forever!. I could not tolerate the night spint, and the doctor told me that was not uncommon.  Anyway, I went for physical therapy. After working on equipment to get rid of the acute pain, I continued exercises at home, got custom orthotics.  It took a good 6 weeks before I was completely better.  Also, the therapist gave me a golf ball which I keep in my dresser drawer. You place it under the arch of your foot and roll it around, pressing down using your heel also.  It hurts, during the stage where you still have pain, but gradually the pain starts to feel better. Also, calf stretches daily--calves, you say--no pain there; well it is connected and the calf stretching does help. I do it each day when I get out of bed even though I am pain free now.. You have to keep up the treatment, so it does not come back. Best of luck.

Gyspy lee.

Spirit seeker said to gypsylee 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

For those who find the golf balls especially painful, you can also use a slightly larger rubber Pinkie Ball, or others, which have a bit more give to them. 

Di Anderson said to Spirit seeker 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

My dr suggested that I use a frozen bottle of water and roll it back and forth under my foot when I sat down. It works, using ice, gets the exercise I need in that area, gets the blood flowing to the foot, and keeps me cool in the summer.

I sit on my deck in the afternoon after a hard day of walking and roll the bottle back and forth under my foot. No effort and so "cool", literally and figuratively. Good use for water. It could be a frozen Diet Coke too if you wanted to use that. :) My solution is cool. 

laurjoan said to Di Anderson 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

I agree with the icing each day - its very necessary for the inflamation when you have plantar fasciitis also having good support shoes - no flats - New Balance are great. Orthodics work well for some but not all. everyone has to find their comfort level.  My warning signs are "red" soles and burning sensation - feels like walking on a bed of hot coals. I personally feel that for me, the very last remedy would be a operation. I had it in both feet, took a year to finally go away, that was about 4 years ago and now its starting all over again.  I am going to try that golf ball remedy - can't hurt!  back to the ice again! 

NancyB said to laurjoan 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

just reading your post while sitting iceing with water bottle and then golf ball.  I've still got it in both feet...1 yr. 4 mos. It was bad in my left foot to begin with so took a yr. and it's better, but now my right foot is worse so starting all over.  I've been in crocs and new balance ever since it began...podiatrist put me on mobic, did cortizone shots in both feet, 3 mos of physical therapy, custom orthotics which I wear constantly and oh I sleep in hard night splints...never dreamed I could ever do that, but I've gotten soooo used to them that I can't sleep without them.  I do know they say you can never let your guard down with this. Keep doing the golf ball thing and your icing. I've started putting a heating pad under my calves before I get out of bed in a.m. and stretching while I'm there...read that runners do this.  Again, so sorry it's come back...feel your pain.

1 member loves this!
Spirit seeker said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

As I posted previously please be aware that cortizone shots can actually cause deterioration of the injected joint, & that means permanent damage.  There is a shot with a product called Traumeel which has no side effects other than pain relief.

Also - besides heating the calves do work on them with massage - plus stretching your foot out pointing the toes & doing ankle circles alternating with rotations clockwise then counterclockwise several times.  Also using the golf balls or more of a rubber ball can help, along with icing.  In addition you can stand on a bottom stair step (please hold the railing for support) placing the front of the foot on the step.  Very slowly put your weight down on that foot as if you were going to climb the stairs - do this 3 or 4 times (you can always work your way up to more) then switch feet and do the other side.  By working on yourself it will gradually help to release both the feet, ankles & calves - all of which should make a change for the better.

From your description of the pain shifting from one foot to the other - it may be that you have some issues with the back muscles & the hips being overly tight.  If that's accurate for you then I would strongly suggest you see a good medical massage or deep tissue massage  therapist who practices Myofascial Release, and Structural Integration techniques (like KMI or Rolfing) or a practitioner of Active Isolated Stretching (look up stretchingusa.com for more info on that technique - also called AIS). 

AIS is helpful for everyone from professional level athletes to anyone who has been in accidents, recovering from strokes or dealing with a hunchback (aka Kyphosis) even scoliosis (curvature of the spine).  Having taken a class in this technique (would love to take more of them - as taught by the originator Aaron Mattes) I have seen miracles happen for people with numorous restrictions in thier bodies.   And I can't say enough good things about the Structural Integration technique KMI either (as taught by Tom Meyers) It freed my own body up tremendously when I had it done - though it does require multiple sessions to release various segments of the body a bit at a time. 

You can often find practitioners by going online to look up schools or the instructors for classes in these modalities - many of them have state by state listings of practitioners who have graduated from their programs.  Do not bother with spa type sessions as they are rarely geared toward specific medical type treatments - but rather what we in the profession call fluff & buff...everything from facials, to swedish and reflexology - all of which is fine if that's what you are looking for - but rarely effective for conditions such as this. 

If you would like more info. please let me know & I'll do my best to point you in the right direction and possibly help you locate someone who can work with you.

Good luck & all the best to you,  hope this wasn't to much info all at once - but helping others to get through various conditions, and move beyond them with at least good improvement is what I do!

Deborah

MrsB said to NancyB 02/23/2010, 12:16PM new!

Arch support in your shoes is vital to stopping the pain. It was the one thing that helped me the most, as pain meds were useless. I have never had this pain again after the initial week of getting uses to new shoe inserts. Thinking back, I remember a few years ago going with my mother to Nordstrom's to try on soft leather shoes. Came to find out that my size 10 feet had morphed into size 11!! My arches had fallen. Perhaps I was then a prime candidate for Plantar Faciitis in the future. It all makes sense now. The funniest thing is that I have found some of the most wonderful sites for size 11 shoes, not available at Macy's or many of the other stores. Wal-Mart sometimes carries 11's but not JC Penney, which you have to catalog order just to try them on when they arrive. If you don't already know, www.zappos.com has an extensive line of well-made shoes, free pick up and delivery. Not cheap shoes but well made and easy return poilcy if they aren't to your liking. Shoes in every size out of the norm, too.

 

Pure and Natural